The 15-Year Career Pivot: Why Small Questions Beat Big Decisions

It took me 15 years to go from "I know engineering isn't right for me" to actually doing something else with my life.

Not 15 years of agonizing every day. Fifteen years of knowing, quietly, and not yet having the language for what to do about it. If you're feeling stuck or lost in your own career transition right now, this is for you.

I recently sat down with executive coach Amelia Noel — who took her own 15-year route from journalism to advertising to consulting to investment banking to coaching — and we talked about what we now call the messy middle: the long, undefined stretch between knowing something isn't working and actually doing something different about it.

If you're in that stretch right now, here's what we learned.

Why Overthinkers Get Stuck in a Career Pivot

Amelia put this more bluntly than I ever have: "Our pros and cons list and our internal conversations 100% reflect our past experiences, our pathways of thinking, our biases."

That list you keep rewriting isn't evidence. It's a mirror. And it's mostly reflecting what you're afraid of, not what's actually true. This is the core reason overthinkers get stuck in a career pivot — the analysis feels like progress, but it's actually just fear, repeating itself in a different font.

The fix isn't more analysis. It's talking to people who've actually made the career change you're considering — not to get permission, but to interrupt the loop. Their lived experience breaks you out of your own head in a way that more internal debate never will.

Your Brain Only Runs the Negative Career Change Scenario

"Our brain loves to focus on the negative what ifs — it never thinks about the positive what ifs."

What if you quit and it doesn't work out? You've run that scenario a hundred times. What if you quit and in a year you have your time back, you feel like yourself again, and the fear was the most expensive part of the whole transition? You've probably never let yourself finish that sentence.

Both are equally possible. Your brain just refuses to rehearse the second one — which is exactly why a career transition can feel so much riskier than it actually is.

How to Stop Overthinking a Career Decision: Ask a Smaller Question

This is the part of the conversation that actually changed how I think about my own story, and it's the most useful answer I've found for how to stop overthinking a career decision.

I didn't decide to leave engineering by sitting down and asking "what do I want to do with my life?" I asked something much smaller: do I enjoy being more creative? And I tested it by making greeting cards. No business plan, no spreadsheet. Just me, asking customers what they wanted the card to say, and noticing how alive that made me feel.

That 2% of my personality I let out into the world eventually became 100%. But it started as a craft project, not a five-year plan.

Amelia's version of this: "Taking bigger and making it smaller. Big questions like what do I want to do next, into smaller questions like — how would I feel if I infused more creativity into my life?"

You don't need the answer. You need the next small experiment. This is, structurally, how most successful career transitions actually happen — not as one big decision, but as a string of small, answerable questions.

Why Talking About a Career Change Feels Scarier Than It Is

I felt embarrassed even bringing up that I was unhappy in engineering. Like I was somehow disrespecting the degree, the years, the identity I'd built. Amelia named exactly why that fear is almost always wrong:

"99% of people, when you say 'I'm thinking of making a career change,' will be supportive. You will be so surprised at how many people want to help."

When she told her team she was leaving banking, the response wasn't judgment. It was: "I wish I could do what you're doing."

You're not bothering anyone by being honest about feeling stuck. You're often giving them permission to say something they've been sitting on too.

How Long Does a Career Transition Take? Longer Than You Think — and That's Normal

This is the line that's stayed with me the most:

"The decisions you made based on your values, your vision, your goals, what you want out of life today — those are aligned decisions. Trying to make a decision that 22-year-old you would have liked creates misalignment in your life and career today, because you're not that person anymore."

You're allowed to update. Choosing differently now doesn't mean your past decisions were wrong. It means you grew — which is the entire point, and which is also why a real career transition rarely happens fast.

If you're in your own messy middle right now — overthinking, overanalyzing, waiting to feel certain before you move — you're not behind, and you're not broken. You're in the middle of a process that almost always takes longer and feels messier than anyone tells you it will.

The way out isn't a better plan. It's a smaller question, answered through action.

 

If you're a mid or senior-level professional in a demanding corporate career and you recognize yourself in any of this — the overworking, the perfectionism, the inability to slow down long enough to ask what you actually want — Amelia's work might be exactly the next step.

A few ways to go deeper with her:

🎯 Take the free 3-minute BFG Mindset Quiz to find out which mindset is driving your stress, overwhelm, and overworking — and get customized tools to start shifting it today: Take the quiz

📞 Book a consult call to talk about enrolling in Breaking Free from the Grind, her 12-week 1:1 coaching program for accelerating your career without sacrificing your sanity: Book a call

🎧 Listen to her podcast, Breaking Free from the Grind, airing every Friday at 9am EST: Listen here

🌐 Learn more about her work: amelianoelcoaching.com

 

Want to hear the full conversation?

This post is based on my conversation with Amelia Noel on Your Life Unbounded — episode 2. Listen to the whole thing wherever you get your podcasts:

🎧 Listen on Spotify

🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts

📺 Watch on YouTube

 
Gloria Julien Coaching

Gloria Julien is an ICF-certified life and career coach who helps overthinkers move through career transitions with clarity and confidence. A former mechanical engineer and UX designer, she treats career change like a design problem — building evidence, testing in real time, and engineering a path forward with precision. She's the host of the podcast Your Life Unbounded.

For podcast updates, workshop announcements, and tools to help you quit overthinking and actually move — follow along on Instagram @gloriajuliencoaching →

https://gloriajulien.com
Next
Next

Stuck in a Career Transition? Why Overthinkers Get Stuck — and How to Get Unstuck